Archives for Karen A. Frenkel

Browse All

Living in Sim: A Multimedia Meditation on Healthcare Today

Friday, January 22nd, 2010

Picture 1

Artist Justine Cooper has found an unusual way to express her frustration with our health care system; she’s created characters out of dressed-up medical mannequins. On her quirky social media site, these mannequins represent doctors, patients, and employees at a fictional Midwestern clinic.

Cooper describes the site as a “mixed reality artwork,” and titled it “Living in Sim,” Last fall, the mannequins also were installed at NYC’s Daneyal Mahmood Gallery.

The medical mannequins endure a dysfunctional health care system just like ours—Cooper uses them as surrogates. Their interactions, she says, reveal “our sense of identity, culture, and healthcare in a technologically advanced society.”

Cooper, through the mannequins, also blogs about topics such as the ethics of face transplants, plastic surgery and universal health care, to name a few. Through their contrived posts, Cooper comments on peoples’ obsessions with how they present themselves online.

Her site even includes fictional sponsors, displaying pharmaceutical company ads. My favorite spoof is the ad for Havidol—Avafynetyme HCL—Future PHARMS, Inc.’s medication when “more is not enough.” The copy, self-assessment quiz, graphics and patient information insert are pitch-perfect. A pdf comes complete with molecular formula, clinical pharmacology (“mechanism of action has been shown to bind to receptors for the newly recognized hormone, hedonine”), results of in vitro studies, pharmacokinetics, clinical trials, etc.

The tone of Havidol’s Important Safety Information matches today’s TV ads: “Havidol should be taken indefinitely. Side effects may include mood changes, muscle strain, extraordinary thinking, dermal gloss…” Levitra anyone? It’s so convincing that site visitors have emailed asking where they can buy the product, says Cooper.

content_male

Unfortunately, we recognize ourselves in the garish mannequins, who collude with a healthcare system, that, like ours, profits from sickness. Moreover, Cooper believes “insurance providers within our current health care system deem human beings to be commodities.” And online, like plastic dummies, “We are opened up, inspected, under surveillance, recorded, intervened with, and manifested into something that becomes part of a system.”

So if you live in sin, you can have it all. But at quite a price.

You can follow LIS on Twitter and on Facebook.

[Image Credit: Justine Cooper and the Daneyal Mahmood Gallery.]

Eric Kandel’s Quest: In Search of Memory

Friday, January 8th, 2010
kandel1[Credit: Angela Radulescu, flickr.com]

In Search of Memory, Petra Seeger’s documentary portraying Nobel Laureate Eric Kandel, is a manifestation of the associative quality of the human mind. It is a masterfully cut film that toggles back and forth in time.

Neurobiologist Kandel shared the Nobel Prize in 2000 in Physiology or Medicine for showing how memory is encoded in the brain’s neuronal circuits. He also showed that we harbor long-term memories because of changes in the genes of brain cells.

The film is named after Kandel’s 2007 biography: In Search of Memory: The Emergence of a New Science of Mind. The documentary intermingles footage from events in Kandel’s Columbia University laboratory, his career, interviews, lectures, family life, and  trips to Vienna where Kandel lived before World War II until age nine, and Brooklyn where he grew up.

The cumulative effect is that viewers sense how deeply Kandel’s scientific quest is enmeshed with scars he bears as a child refugee. In one segment, for example, he explains his early work on recording axons firing in a hippocampus. In another, he returns to his father’s shop in Vienna, where he chats with the current owner who claims to be honored to meet him.

In a particularly excruciating sequence, Kandel walks through Vienna’s Heldenplatz, where 200,000 people welcomed Hitler. Kandel describes the brutal actions Austrian Jews endured starting that day. Then the viewer hears a shriek over the archival footage. Seeger cuts to a closeup of an eye. Two more screams.

As Kandel describes research in his lab on traumatic memories, the film shows that the eye belongs to a male student test subject who is undergoing an MRI. The purpose of the experiment is to document the lasting effect of traumatic memories. The student is shown an open circle as he hears the recorded scream. Then, the MRI reveals changes in the student’s brain when he sees the open circle without hearing the scream. He has been conditioned to perceive the scream whenever he sees the circle, even when he hears nothing.

“All I can do is the best science I can,” says Kandel, who laments those lost in the Holocaust, including people “smarter than I.”  He is resilient and jovial despite his close knowledge of the horrors people can inflict upon one another. He remembers how scary it was to flee Vienna with only his 12-year-old brother and to not know where his parents were for many months. Then, in a search that parallels his Vienna expedition, he revisits the Brooklyn neighborhood where he and his brother reunited with their grandparents in 1939. He jokes with old-timers and asks if they remember his father’s haberdashery shop. He visits his apartment and alma maters.

Yet Kandel’s memories never paralyze him. If anything, they seem to have propelled him.

Because he narrates his story, I wondered about Seeger’s decision to produce and direct re-enactments of Kandel’s childhood Vienna memories. After all, these are intimate recollections. In one reenactment, Seeger shows a young actor playing Kandel who has just received a remote control toy car for his ninth birthday. Two Nazis walk in on him and his mother and order them to leave. Kandel, 70 years later, tells us that when they returned later, their home had been ransacked—even his toy car was gone.

I asked Kandel how he felt about those segments and if they matched his mind’s eye. “I felt very awkward about it,” he said. “The fact that my role was played by a young boy and my mother by an actress––I wasn’t happy with that.” Although uncomfortable with parts of the film, Kandel praises Seeger as an expressionist artist who amplified aspects of his personality and his family most interesting to her. As a result, “certain aspects of my character emerge more profoundly in the movie,” he says, “They are absolutely real, but I don’t laugh 90 percent of the time and I’m not that Jewish 90 percent of the time.”

One of the film’s most triumphant and moving moments is when Kandel elegantly bows to the King of Sweden and members of the Nobel committee. Click here for his Nobel prize speech. Had he just conducted “the best science,” Kandel’s contribution would have been impressive. But he went on to write his biography, participated in this film and is now writing another book about a Viennese salon where scientists and artists shared ideas.

I asked Kandel what drives him to keep working when he could sit back and relax. Some very successful Holocaust survivors I have known have indicated that they wanted to show the world that Hitler did not win, that European Jews are still here.

Kandel simply said, “I do it because it’s fun.”

Ken Burns’ National Parks: from Scenery to Science – Part Two

Tuesday, November 24th, 2009

The continuation of my interview (see the first part here) with filmmaker Ken Burns:

KAF: At one point Dayton Duncan says that all he learned about science, he learned at the national parks and he emphasizes the role of rangers. There’s a dearth of students enrolling in science, technology and math programs now in the U.S. Do you see the parks as a way of rekindling peoples’ appreciation for ecology and science in general? (more…)

The Attraction of Magnetic Movie

Friday, November 13th, 2009

Imagine Science Film Festival’s Nature Scientific Merit Award went to Magnetic Movie, a 4-minute, 47-second short by Ruth Jarman and Joe Gerhardt of Semiconductor Films. Theirs was one of 50 films representing 9 countries and selected from over 250 submissions.
Here’s the link to this mysterious work of art, possibly about science and possibly not. More about that in a moment.

The British artists spent five months at the NASA’s Space Sciences Laboratory at UC Berkeley under a fellowship from England’s Arts Council. The film is intriguing both because of its subject and the techniques used to glean information, interpret it, and represent it.

(more…)

The Science View

Monday, October 26th, 2009

Like many women, I was excited about the number of women who received Nobel Prizes earlier this month. It seemed like a dismissal of Larry Summers’ famous remarks when he was president of Harvard that women are less capable in the sciences than men. Here’s my fantasy TV show, The View reimagined, if it covered events in the science milieu.

CHELSEA: Oh wow, what a Nobel week that was! All those women scientists—Elizabeth Blackburn and Carol Greider for medicine. Ada Yonath for chemistry. I’m totally thrilled. (more…)

Ken Burns’ National Parks: from Scenery to Science

Tuesday, October 20th, 2009

Part One

Ken Burns’ new series, The National Parks: America’s Best Idea premiered on Public Television stations nationwide during the last week of September. By the end of the first episode, I immediately recognized that this opus differed from past works––Burns was tackling a history involving scientists, their passions, and their activism. I spoke with Burns about the motivation for the series, which he began to formulate ten years ago. (more…)

Science Jobs
JMP
Tasty Mug
Support for Science Friday provided in part by the Noyce Foundation
and
The Alfred P. Sloan Foundation
The National Science Foundation
Research Corporation for Science Advancement