THIS WEEK ON
 SCIENCE FRIDAY...

scifri rainbow logo


Science Friday > Archives > 2001 > June > June 22, 2001:

Hour Two: Access to Scientific Journals

The U.S. government pours millions of tax dollars a year into scientific research. The results of that research usually are published in scientific journals. However, not everyone has access to these reports, and the access that does exist generally isn't free.

Publishers, who produce scientific and scholarly journals sell subscriptions to research libraries and individuals, often at considerable prices. Often, the publishers hold copyright to articles submitted for publication. Although the publishers do have significant costs for their own staff of editors, page layout people, and distribution channels, they do not pay scientists for their manuscripts or the experts that conduct the essential scientific "peer review" process. The publishers control who has access to the published information, and at what price.

With the advent of the Internet and easy electronic access to information, some researchers have become dissatisfied with this arrangement. They want to collect articles in open archives that anyone could search free of charge. More than 24,000 biomedical scientists have signed on to an open letter proposing a "Public Library of Science" initiative, asking publishers to make scientific reports freely available six months after publication. These scientists threaten to boycott publishers who don¹t comply, starting in September of this year.

Some scientists in other areas of research, such as physics and mathematics, already store their articles on pre-print and e-print servers. This practice is tolerated by most publishers.

Who should control access to the scientific literature--scientists or publishers? Can publishers survive if they give away their product for free? Could scientists survive without publishers? Is there common ground? And why should you.if you're neither a scientist or a publisher.care about this issue? Call in with your questions and comments at 1-800-989-8255, and share your opinions online in our Listeners' Lounge (registration required)

RealAudio Icon

Listen to this program in RealAudio!

 

Guests:
Dr. Harold Varmus
1989 Nobel Laureate, Physiology or Medicine
Former Director, National Institutes of Health
President, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
New York, New York

Karen Hunter
Senior Vice President, Strategy for the combined Science, Technical, Medical Businesses
Elsevier Science Inc.
New York, New York

Ann Okerson
Associate Director for Collections and Technical Services
Yale University Libraries
New Haven, Connecticut  

Books/Articles Discussed:

 

(find more SciFri books here)

Search for books on:

Related Links:
Public Library of Science: Home
Scientific American: Explore!: Publish Free or Perish: April 23, 2001
PubMed Central Home
Nature Debates: e-access
Science Discussion: A Public Archive for the Primary Scientific Literature?
BioMed Central
Open Archives Initiative
arXiv.org e-Print archive
Physics on the Web Is Putting Science Journals on the Line

American Scientist: Walker - Introduction
Association of Research Libraries
Epub Standards Report
STM: International Association of Scientific, Technical & Medical Publishers

This segment produced by: Julia Karow
Web Producer: Charles Bergquist


Have questions, comments, suggestions about the radio show? Contact us at scifri@npr.org.
Send questions, comments, suggestions about the site to
producer@sciencefriday.com .

Science Friday® and sciencefriday.com are produced by ScienceFriday Inc. "Science Friday" is a registered service mark.
Host/Executive Producer/Editor of Science Friday: Ira Flatow
Senior Producer of Science Friday: Karin Vergoth

Executive web producer: Ira Flatow

Web producer: Charles Bergquist

Copyright 2001 ScienceFriday Inc. All Rights Reserved.