S C I E N C E   F R I D A Y ®

SciFri Navbar

 

 

 

Questions about the show? mail them to scifri@npr.org

Questions/Comments about this site? Send them to producer@
sciencefriday.com

Web Producer:
Charles Bergquist

Executive Web Producer: Ira Flatow

© 1998, All Rights Reserved.

 

       

 

Last week, we asked you to tell us about the risks from asteroids crashing into the Earth. Here's what you said...

35 listeners were concerned about asteroids - 36 were not. Here are some excerpts from your mail...


Alex Bozzi, IV

If it misses, then no problem.

If it hits....then no problem.


JMY

They've hit us before, they'll hit us again. Nasty things they are.


patterson

Yes, we are concerned since no one can say with 100% certainty that it will not occur. Hopefully, it will not be in the next 2000 years!


Ace Armstrong

We do, of course, have to be worried about asteroid or cometary impacts. It's almost impossible to track everything headed to Earth from every angle, and we all know that celestial impacts occur. Examples include the comet (Levy-Shoemaker, right?) that crashed into Jupiter, the various craters we have been able to find on our own planet, and the quite obvious craters found on other planets. You have to play the odds, and realize that eventually we *will* be hit by *something* large. Maybe not today . . .but, then again, maybe today after all. WE have no way of knowing.


Dennis Murray

Most people are relieved that 1997XF11 will miss the Earth, I wish it had been headed our way. Asteroids have hit us before and will continue to do so. As asteroids go, this one was nearly ideal. It is too big to ignore so we would have been forced to act; but still small enough to be dealt with effectively. ... Also, it was just possible that the people of Earth would finally start putting aside some of their more petty pursuits, such as war, ecological destructruction, and racial and ethnic hatreds.


Gail Dahlquist

I am more interested in the idea of an asteroid striking Earth than I am concerned. Asteroids have always been striking planets and moons. Though the probablility of a devastating strike to Earth in the very near future is low now, time is not on our side.


Patrick Brassil

No - Not about this particular asteroid, anyway.

Especially with the terrific opportunity that this would present to us- If we could capture it as it went by, and work it into an orbit around the earth, we'd have a completely natural space-station, one that we could work on by simply drilling into the rock! It would be a monumental step in our plans for colonizing the stars, if only our leaders were level-headed enough to recognize it as the opportunity it clearly is.


Leigh Keller

I am more concerned about the overall state of humanity and the impending dangers of mankinds impact on the earth than an asteroid.


Douglas Strausbaugh

I work in the healthcare industry in home health. Catching mrsa, antibiotic resistant TB, or one of those other infectious diseases that you talked about on 3-13 is much more real to me. Also dealing with bad traffic while travelling from one person's home to the next is a much more immediate concern. Theses are things I can affect with my behavior. An asteroid will smack the earth whether I worry about it or not.


Thanks to all of you who took the time to write in!