SciFri
 FEEDBACK

scifri rainbow logo

     

    Last week's topic: Alternative Operating Systems.

    We asked what operating systems you used, and if you would consider switching... and boy, did you respond!

    252 of you wrote in, breaking down as follows...

  • 83 Linux users
  • 77 Windows users
  • 32 Mac users
  • 30 OS2 users
  • 13 FreeBSD users
  • 7 Solaris users
  • 7 DOS users
  • 2 BE OS users
  • 1 NeXT user

    Many people used more than one operating system, or used one at home and another at work. Here are a few highlights...


    Brian Bough

    I really have to ask why this show continues to bash Microsoft. About every other week we hear from experts who defy what is clearly the popular sentiment that Microsoft continues to deliver the superior product. How can I make that statement? Just look around at the computers you see daily. It becomes obvious that Microsoft and Intel (IBM clones) machines were never really threatened by Macs, much less anyone else. What would it take for me to change? I would need a OS that would give me security (like Win 4.0--NT,'95,'98), performance (like Win 4.0), and would run the applications I've purchased for Win 4.0. I would also need solid networking capabilities with a good graphics user interface (GUI) like Win 4.0. If I have Win'95, Win'98, or Win NT, why would I want any other operating system? Microsoft has laid the groundrules for software development and Intel has done the same in the hardware side. Now it is up to software manufacturers to develop applications that will work with MS technology. Doing otherwise is like spitting into the wind.


    Tony Anton

    My operating system for the past 5 years has been OS/2. It's configurability and dependability is unbeaten. I might consider switching to Linux if a user interface equal to OS/2's Work Place Shell would be available. This is doubtful since the WPS is so strongly object based. In another two or three years look for a pure Java OS. Since Java is object based, a clone of the WPS might be available.

    For what it's worth, OS/2 is just plain fun to use. With the addition of the second party Object Desktop it becomes a snap for beginners. I have started three people out in OS/2 who had never done a thing with a computer previously


    Kenneth Furge

    I have already made the switch at my home and work to FreeBSD. An electrical engineer by trade and software hacker by hobby, I prefer the power and flexibility of unix. Windows and its derivatives feels like computing in a straightjacket.


    Scott Liebergen

    I use Linux everyday at home and at work. Although when I have to communicate with users that have sent me Microsoft Word documents (in the newer Office 97 format) I unfortunately have to switch to my sluggish Windows NT machine.

    It has been my experience, that Linux is the swiss army knife of all OS's. It comes with many extra's ,is freely available from many places on the web(for the price of a download) and support is available from the internet community in a matter of minutes.

    Oh and best of all, it does not crash...unlike ...er other operating systems we know... :-)


    Douglas Britsch

    I have been using the BeOS for about a year now. The OS rocks, there is no comparison with windows. If I weren't using the Be I would be using Linux, or some Unix variants. Windows is slow and chunkie and crashes way too much. As for what I would recommend for a mear computing mortal, I think I would have to recommend the Mac. For ease of use, setup, and troubleshooting it can't be beat


    Dave Koehler

    What operating system do I use? Mac OS.

    What would make would make me willing to switch? $10,000 ???


    Amit Kumar

    What about DOS? DOS offers something that few other "alternative OS's" an very large base of existing applications. The FreeDOS project has finally started to fly. They have a fairly stable kernel with new one coming out soon. I am certain that they will have a fully working distribution in the not to distant future. And the DOSzilla project, which I am leading, is working on getting Mozilla, the Netscape Navigator source code, ported to DOS. Advantages of DOS: DOS is free, Easy to setup up,Works with the vast majority of PC hardware, Has a large application base, Can run well on old, low end hardware

 

Talk of the Nation: Science Friday® is a science talk show which can be heard each Friday afternoon, 2-4 pm Eastern Time over public radio. SciFri is hosted by veteran NPR science correspondent Ira Flatow. Have questions, comments, suggestions about the show? Contact us at scifri@npr.org. Send questions, comments, suggestions about the site to producer@sciencefriday.com .

A note to our listeners: News is always breaking in the scientific community, and Science Friday tries to be as up-to-date as possible. For that reason, these listings are tentative, and subject to change. We will make every effort to keep listings complete and current -- check back often!

Science Friday® is produced by ScienceFriday Inc.., and is a registered service mark.

The Science Friday® Web site is a production of ScienCentral, Inc.

Executive web producer: Ira Flatow

Web producer: Charles Bergquist

Copyright© ScienCentral, Inc., 1998, all rights reserved.