01/05/2018

The SciFri Book Club: ‘Frankenstein’

8:34 minutes

green frankenstein face
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

A brilliant young scientist, Victor Frankenstein, creates life out of a jumble of body parts—only to turn his back on his bewildered creation and leave it to fend for itself. Are the murders that ensue Dr. Frankenstein’s fault? Both Frankenstein and his monster tell their stories in the pages of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein—the #SciFriBookClub’s winter book pick. Join Ira and the SciFri team as we read Mary Shelley’s spooky science fiction tale this month, and ask what it means to be human.

[The future of human gene editing is promising—but still uncertain.]

First published in 1818, Shelley’s book drew inspiration from the electricity experiments of Luigi Galvani and Alessandro Volta in the late 1700s. Now, in the story of a creator abandoning its creation, which then wreaks havoc upon the world, many see ethical equivalents in conversations around CRISPR, self-driving cars, and even big data. We’ll read and discuss questions like this all month long. And we want to hear from you! (Your comments may be played on the air.)

do you see any parallels between frankenstein and science today? call u567-243-2456

Want to get in on the SciFri Book Club conversation? Here’s how to participate:

  1. Grab a copy of the book and start reading! Our drawing for a free copy of the novel has closed, but the story is free to the public online in a number of places. Check out Frankenbook.org, where the story is annotated by contemporary scientists and comes with several essays about its modern relevance. Still not sure if you want to jump in? Start with this excerpt, in which the monster first confronts his creator.
  2. Sign up for our SciFri Book Club newsletter to stay updated on extra reading suggestions, discussion questions, and events related to the Book Club.
  3. Take part in our wrap-up discussion of the Book Club by calling in to the broadcast on Friday, February 9. Discuss the book with Ira and our special guest readers, speculative fiction author Elizabeth Bear, and Hastings Center bioethicist Josephine Johnston.
  4. Can’t wait to join the conversation? Join the #SciFriBookClub discussion on Twitter, or leave us a voicemail! We want to know: Do you see any parallels between Frankenstein and science today? Give us a ring at 567-243-2456. Your comments may be played on the air.
  5. Keep checking back here over the next five weeks! There’s much more Frankenstein to come.

Questions about the Club? Post ‘em in the comments below or email bookclub@sciencefriday.com. Happy reading!


Stay up to speed with the SciFri Book Club Newsletter!

Segment Guests

Christie Taylor

Christie Taylor is a producer for Science Friday. Her day involves diligent research, too many phone calls for an introvert, and asking scientists if they have any audio of that narwhal heartbeat.

Segment Transcript

IRA FLATOW: OK, so you’ve been spending your winter curled up with various good books. You might want to consider adding another to your shelf, because the sci-fi book club is getting back together, and we’ve got a monster– get it? You’ll see where I’m going. A tale for you here, featuring the original mad scientist Dr. Victor Frankenstein.

That’s right. We’re reading Mary Shelley’s classic science fiction novel about a man who creates a monster. And nothing personal, we want you to join us. Sci-fi radio producer and book club captain, Christie Taylor, is with me to tell you more about this month’s book club and how you can join in. Hey there, Christie.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Hey, Ira. How’s it going?

IRA FLATOW: Let’s talk about this.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: So Frankenstein– you might be wondering why we picked this. Well, the timing is actually very good. It is a nice, round anniversary for the publication of Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein. She wrote it in 1816 when she was 18 years old, one rainy summer at Lake Geneva. And it was published on January 1st of 1818, so 200 years old and still looking great.

IRA FLATOW: So, OK. So it’s the 200th anniversary. There’s got to be a science reason why we’re reading this one.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Sure! Well, as you might remember from the story, it involves reanimating a corpse with– at least as we’re seeing in the movies– lightning. This is about the time that Luigi Galvani and Alessandro Volta were fighting about why, if you ran electricity through a frog leg, it twitched. A dead frog leg. They had a big fight about this in the late 1700s. Long story short, we got to reanimating a monster with some lightning bolts.

It’s also actually really timely in a lot of other ways, because it brings us to these really interesting conversations about the ethics of creating life, if you’re not going to actually maybe make sure it’s successful or even well-balanced. In the book at least, we see that the monster– as we hear it referred to– maybe could have been a better guy, if he’d had a little bit more nurturing. And this has some ties to maybe CRISPR, AI, even big data if you ask some of the people that think about this kind of stuff.

IRA FLATOW: Well, you mentioned the monster, and we were talking about this earlier. If you just think that the book is like the films, the monster is not at all like the film, right? Like we’ve seen in both films. Gene Wilder in the original, Boris Karloff–

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Right, and that famous, it’s alive, it’s alive. Which we don’t actually see in the book.

IRA FLATOW: It’s not in the book.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: He doesn’t say anything. Well, if he said anything, we don’t know. He’s just very excitedly writing about it. But yeah, the monster is still very big, still very ugly. That’s sort of its biggest crime is being ugly. But there’s no bolts in the neck, no scar on the forehead as far as we know. And he has pretty good hair, apparently lustrous black hair that just makes his sallow face look a little bit more disturbing.

And he’s also very articulate. We actually hear a lot from him in the book. He tells us his life story, which is pretty interesting because he goes off exploring. And there’s this really beautiful scene, actually, right in the very beginning, where we have this image. A ship captain is talking about being stuck in the Arctic among the icebergs. And he looks out one night, and he sees this giant, hulking figure on a dog sled going through the night across the ice. And that’s not something you get to see in the movies.

IRA FLATOW: No, because there’s the lightning storm in the movie. So that would be summer time. OK, so we’re sold on doing the book. How do we get copies of the book?

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Well, the first thing you need to remember in all of this is our web site sciencefriday.com/bookclub. That’s going to be your one stop shop for pretty much everything related to playing along. And for starters, we are giving away 20 free copies that will be shipped to you for free on our website. This is a copy that was put out by MIT Press in collaboration with Arizona State University last year. It is annotated, with all sorts of helpful information from modern scientists and thinkers to people who have studied Mary Shelley herself. So you get a lot of the historical context, as well as some questions to think about moving forward.

And that is on our web site sciencefriday.com/bookclub. That form to enter will close at 10:00 PM Sunday night so we can catch our weekend listeners. But the good news is, if you don’t get one of those copies, this is a story that is in the public domain. It’s available for free online in a lot of different places. That annotated version is also for free online at frankenbook.org if that piques your interest.

And then, we have an excerpt to get you started– if you’re still on the fence– at our web site sciencefriday.com/bookclub.

IRA FLATOW: Of course, this is science. This is Science Friday from PRI, Public Radio International. Talking with Christie Taylor, associate producer and also honcho of this book club for Frankenstein. OK, so once we’re reading, how do we play along at home, Christie?

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Well Ira, there are a few options. We’re launching a weekly newsletter, first of all– this is all new for this book club– where you will get some discussion questions if you want to feel like you’re in high school English again. Discussion questions, some articles. There are a lot of people writing and thinking about Frankenstein this year because of this handy anniversary, so we’re going to try to hook you up with all of that great conversation that’s happening on the web and in the world.

And then, we also– if you’re on Twitter– have a hashtag, #scifibookclub, so you can play along all week long for the next five weeks. And then, you can even call our off air voicemail. So this is not the same as our call in number. It is (567) 243-2456. Again, (567) 243-2456 if you want to leave a comment, a thought, a reflection. And we’re going to play some of those on the air each week leading up to a final wrap up conversation with two readers who have been reading and thinking about this book for a while, Elizabeth Bayer, speculative and science fiction author, and Josephine Johnston, a bio-ethicist with the Hastings Center.

IRA FLATOW: And what date are we going to do that?

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Oh, that is on February 9th, Ira.

IRA FLATOW: February 9th.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Yes.

IRA FLATOW: Both of these readers have spent a ton of time thinking about the story. And we’re going to have you read it and let you give us comments. If you want a comment that will play on the air, the number again that Christie gave out is (567) 243-2456. We don’t want a tome that you send. I mean, in both senses of the word, Frankenstein. We want it just to be a little short question or a comment.

Now, you know I’m a big fan of the movie and Gene Wilder’s funny take on it. You already mentioned a lot of the things that are in the movies, and both movies are not in the book. And one key thing to remember that everybody confuses is, the monster is not Frankenstein, right?

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Correct. This is a thing that, I think, people can get maybe a little too pedantic about. But yeah. Victor Frankenstein is your scientist. And he actually doesn’t have a name in the book. Victor Frankenstein called the monster a lot of different, kind of mean names, the creature, the demon. I think he calls him the abortion at one point.

But I think, also, it’s worth reflecting on whether maybe– you know, as we read the book– perhaps Victor Frankenstein himself has some qualities that might not be considered monstrous along the way. So maybe, the monster is Frankenstein.

IRA FLATOW: Or Frankensteen.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: (LAUGHS)

IRA FLATOW: (LAUGHS) Have you started reading? I’m very excited.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Yeah, I’m actually only about halfway through, because I’m savoring every page. And I have a million dog ears and quotes underlined, but I am really excited to get to the end and figure out what happens in this sort of epic duel between the creator and his creation.

IRA FLATOW: And people consider this to be maybe the very first science fiction.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: At the very least, it was the first of modern science fiction. I know Brian Aldiss is someone who’s written a lot about this. He was definitely the first mad scientist in the sub-genre. And I think, actually, that’s a really great question to consider too, as you read. Is he a good scientist? Is he representative of scientists? Could scientists learn anything from him?

IRA FLATOW: And as you say, it is very relevant today, as we talk about the new kinds of stuff being made in laboratories.

CHRISTIE TAYLOR: Yeah, CRISPR, AI again, self-driving cars is out of Frankenstein’s story here. Are we going to regret this creation, or do we need to take better care of it as we go?

IRA FLATOW: To be continued. And that’s a wrap! Thanks so much for coming on. Christie Taylor, associate producer at Science Friday and chief bookworm for the sci-fi book club. Thanks, again.

And again, you can learn more about the book club. Enter to win that free copy of Frankenstein and sign up for the weekly book club newsletter, sciencefriday.com/bookclub.

Copyright © 2017 Science Friday Initiative. All rights reserved. Science Friday transcripts are produced on a tight deadline by 3Play Media. Fidelity to the original aired/published audio or video file might vary, and text might be updated or amended in the future. For the authoritative record of Science Friday’s programming, please visit the original aired/published recording. For terms of use and more information, visit our policies pages at http://www.sciencefriday.com/about/policies/

Explore More